-Oh lordy lordy,
---It's way too hard to type on a cell, so I will refrain from lengthy explainations about computer lingo/etiquette and how an asterisk is used to stress* a word and screaming is done in all upper case. Hence why most screamers are overlooked. However, the issue here I believe is 100% aspiration ... I mean fuel, not the promising will to learn.
---It is true that the fuel bowl is incorrect. The metering plate's numbers don't matc either but that doesn't mean it is incorrect because sometimes* they don't. You'll have to search the board for that list number or even contact someone like M. Mayben (who may have been recording part numbers for the past few years) & there's a real slim possibility that Holley will know what metering plate is correct. Yes, all the stamped numerals mean something, no, even though the 2300 has been my.carb, my favorite, of choice for some 20+ years (on many makes), I don't have a list of part numbers.
---Your Base Plate gasket is correct, though I would suggest a new one. Look at post # 10 of the [URL="http://www.binderplanet.com/forums/showpost.php?p=64838&postcount=10]Useful Part Number Thread[/URL] for "alcohol"-rated parts you should add when you rebuild. You will also need the correct Main Body Gasket for that particular Throttle Plate... Seen it before and it's the troublesome one that is near impossible to obtain. When you purchase the rebuild kit (should be 3-888), you will need to post a clear pic of all gaskets so you can be shown which Main Body Gasket to use. Also, no matter who tells you to tighten the screws "until they're about to strip", ignore & discard the info. Contact Holley and ask them for the torque specs & follow them. All overtightening will do is distort and eventually destroy your invaluable carb.
---There are torque specs and sequence for mounting the carb as well. Follow them and not only will you not* damage (crack or warp) the Throttle Plate, but you'll be able to reuse the Base Plate gasket more than once... LOL. Holley will be able to tell you what size jets, power valve, needle & seat and pump discharge nozzle came stock in that Carb as well.
---Choke is set when cold. Loosen the screws, close choke, open choke, close choke, etc.,etc., until it is just* closed, with as little spring tension as possible, keeping it closed. When it heats up, it will open. Needs to be closed when cold. When warm, if not completely open, it will* open more when needed, when carb intake requests it do so, hence the direction & operation of the visible* choke spring on the end of the shaft.
---It is my belief that the problem begins with mis-matched parts and vacuum leaks.